This excerpt is brought to you by Dollar Scholar, the insightful Money newsletter where news editor Julia Glum shares essential modern financial lessons. Stay ahead of the curve by signing up at money.com/subscribe and become part of our thriving community of over 160,000 Scholars.
Currently, I’m at John F. Kennedy International Airport, eagerly waiting for my early-morning flight to take off. The atmosphere here is far from ideal; there’s a crying baby nearby, all the in-seat power outlets seem to be malfunctioning, and the terminal temperature is so low that I’m seriously contemplating wearing a second sweatshirt for warmth. To add to the chaos, airport attendants frequently come over the intercom, loudly addressing passengers. And let’s not forget about the smoothie I’m sipping on, which set me back a staggering $10!
This experience makes me yearn for the luxury of private lounge access that high-end credit cards often offer as a perk. Unfortunately, none of the cards in my modest portfolio—including the American Express Blue Cash Preferred and the Chase Sapphire Preferred—provide that benefit. Yet, I appreciate that these cards come with low annual fees; all of them are priced under $100.
Now that I think about it…
Understanding the Purpose Behind Credit Card Annual Fees
The rationale for why some credit cards come with annual fees can be traced back to the Credit Card Accountability Responsibility and Disclosure Act of 2009, widely known as the CARD Act. This comprehensive legislation introduced a wealth of consumer protections and fundamentally altered the credit card landscape, as noted by the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. By enhancing transparency and fairness, the CARD Act has provided consumers with greater control and understanding of their credit agreements.
Among its many provisions, the CARD Act prohibited previously common practices such as double-cycle billing, capped late fees, and mandated that new credit card applicants must be at least 21 years old. Most relevant to our discussion is how the law encouraged a shift toward a more straightforward fee structure, as explained by Kelvin Chen, senior executive vice president and head of policy at the Consumer Bankers Association. This transformation has significantly reduced the complexity surrounding credit card fees.
Before the enactment of the CARD Act, consumers faced a proliferation of what critics labeled as “fee-harvester” cards. These cards typically featured minimal credit limits but imposed exorbitantly high fees, effectively trapping users in a cycle of debt. For instance, a card from 2007 advertised a $250 limit; however, after including upfront charges such as a $95 program fee, a $29 account setup fee, a $48 annual fee, and an additional $6 monthly fee, the consumer would only have $72 available for use almost immediately upon signing up.
The CARD Act effectively curtailed these deceptive practices, safeguarding consumers from such predatory tactics.
Today, as per Chen, credit card issuers primarily rely on three main revenue streams. The first source is interchange fees, which merchants pay each time a customer makes a purchase with a credit card. These fees generally range from 1% to 3% of the transaction value, making them a significant source of income for card companies. If you’re curious about the ongoing discussions surrounding interchange fees, my 2023 article on the Credit Card Competition Act provides an in-depth look at the political dynamics involved.
The second source of revenue comes from interest payments made by consumers who carry balances month after month. This method is the main revenue generator for credit card companies, particularly given the high interest rates they charge. By August, the average credit card interest rate across the nation had reached 21.76%, according to data from the St. Louis Fed, which underscores the profitability of this business model.
Lastly, the third revenue source consists of various fees, which encompass annual fees among other charges. This aspect of the credit card industry is particularly intriguing. Over the last few years, while the percentage of Americans paying annual fees has decreased, the total amount generated from these fees has more than doubled—from $3 billion in 2015 to an impressive $6.4 billion in 2022, per the CFPB’s findings.
For card issuers, implementing annual fees can serve to filter out customers who may not be financially responsible, ultimately cultivating a customer base that is more affluent. This strategic decision enhances profitability, according to Vrinda Gupta, CEO and co-founder of Sequin, a startup focused on providing debit card services for women.
Credit card companies aim to attract wealthier individuals because they tend to spend more, which translates into higher income from interchange fees and interest. This interconnectedness is crucial to the companies’ bottom lines.
It’s important to note, however, that not every credit card imposes an annual fee. For example, Money has compiled a list of top no-annual-fee credit cards, including popular options like the American Express Blue Cash Everyday Card and the Chase Freedom Unlimited. In recent years, the prevalence of annual fees has significantly diminished for what the industry terms subprime and deep subprime cards—those aimed at individuals with average or poor credit. Cards that do charge annual fees now predominantly target borrowers with higher credit scores and often come with minimum spending requirements, typically around $3,000 within the first three months, to unlock attractive bonuses.
But here’s the kicker: the average American possesses four credit cards, resulting in a plethora of options. From the perspective of a credit card issuer, the challenge lies in enticing wealthy clients to choose and consistently use their cards over competitors’ offerings.
The solution is straightforward: provide exclusive perks and benefits, such as the coveted lounge access I would have loved while waiting at the airport. Additionally, high annual fees enable card companies to offset the costs associated with offering such premium benefits, enhancing the overall customer experience. I plan to delve deeper into this topic in a future issue.
Key Insights on Credit Card Annual Fees
In essence, credit card annual fees represent a vital revenue stream for card issuers in the evolving landscape shaped by the CARD Act. This dynamic is reciprocal; Gupta emphasizes that issuers of high-fee cards are motivated to deliver value back to consumers to justify the cost of the fee and encourage frequent use of the card.
Explore More Valuable Resources from Money:
Discover if store credit cards are worth your time and money.
Find out when it’s advantageous to apply for a new credit card.
Learn about the reasons behind the popularity of metal credit cards.
