This excerpt is brought to you by Dollar Scholar, the insightful money newsletter where managing editor Julia Glum imparts essential modern money lessons that you absolutely need to know. Don’t miss out on the next issue! Sign up at money.com/subscribe and become part of our thriving community of over 160,000 Scholars.
My cell phone is failing me, and I’m not just referring to its battery life. Over the past few months, my iPhone 13 has become increasingly glitchy, has a grainy display, and is constantly running out of memory; it’s clear that its lifespan is winding down.
However, the thought of purchasing a new cell phone fills me with anxiety. I have vivid memories of standing in an AT&T store with my mom, feeling overwhelmed as an employee tried to upsell us on unnecessary features. Compounding my stress is the fact that this time, I’m contemplating a significant change: buying a phone outright instead of through financing.
Since I was 13, I’ve always financed my cell phones. However, I currently have some cash available, and I’m pondering whether it would be wiser to pay for my new phone in full. This decision could potentially save me money in the long run.
Is It Better to Pay Upfront or Finance Your New Cell Phone?
Various companies use different terminology for what I’m discussing — such as lease-to-own, equipment installment plans, or device payment programs — but the underlying concept remains the same. I have the choice to either pay the total cost of the device in a single lump sum upfront or to make monthly payments until I’ve fully paid it off. (For this discussion, let’s assume I’m purchasing through a carrier.)
For instance, if I want to buy a 128-gigabyte iPhone 16 from Verizon, I can either pay a one-time fee of $829.99 for the phone or choose to make monthly payments of $23.05 over 36 months. At the conclusion of those 36 months, the phone officially becomes mine.
“Your phone is now paid off, and you’re free to unlock it,” proudly states a Boost Mobile FAQ. “No more device charges for this phone on your bill!” This sounds appealing, but it’s crucial to weigh the pros and cons.
Dividing the large payment into smaller, more manageable payments offers both advantages and drawbacks, as noted by Christa O’Brien, a financial advisor with Northwestern Mutual.
“Financing a phone allows you to spread the cost over time,” she explains in an email. “This option helps preserve cash flow, enabling you to save or invest elsewhere while still affording a new phone.” However, it can also lead to financial strain if I overextend my budget.
For example, when T-Mobile breaks down the cost of the Samsung Galaxy Z Flip6 into 24 monthly payments, it comes to just $45.84. That’s significantly easier to manage and rationalize compared to the full price of $1,099.99.
“The initial ease of financing might tempt you to opt for a pricier model than if you were to pay for it outright,” O’Brien cautions. This can lead to a slippery slope, especially since long-term monthly payments could become a burden on my budget.
One crucial aspect to consider is the interest rate associated with the financing plan. Many phone installment plans offer 0% APR, meaning they do not accrue interest, but I must verify this before signing any contract. O’Brien also suggests checking if the monthly installment plan ties me to that carrier until my phone is fully paid off, potentially limiting my flexibility.
Another factor to evaluate is my credit. Some financing plans require soft credit checks to establish eligibility, which do not impact my credit score but are still important to be aware of. Chase notes in a blog post that financing a cell phone can help build credit only if my payment history is reported to the credit bureaus — a detail that many carriers overlook.
For these reasons and more, O’Brien suggests that opting for the lump sum payment may be a wiser choice. Not only do I avoid interest payments or additional financing charges, but many retailers also offer discounts or promotions for upfront purchases, making it even more attractive.
However, the challenge here is that it requires a significant upfront payment. This can strain my budget or deplete savings that I should ideally reserve for emergencies. Additionally, the rapid depreciation of mobile phones means that “the initial expense may feel less justified over time,” O’Brien points out.
So how should I navigate this complex decision?
Firstly, it’s essential to understand that the cost of the phone is not the only financial factor I need to consider. Luis Silva, AT&T vice president and general manager for Florida, advises beginning with research into what equipment I truly need — should I go for an Android or an Apple phone, and what features are essential (AI capabilities, better camera, increased memory, etc.)?
While my instinct may be to upgrade to the latest model, it’s likely that I don’t actually need the newest version filled with the latest features and upgrades.
“The great thing about phones that are a little older is that they still perform exceptionally well, and you can often find them at a discounted price,” Silva explains. “It’s similar to when you purchase a car from the previous model year.”
Next, I should inquire about potential discounts for trading in my current device. Depending on its model and condition, I could receive a bill credit of up to $1,300, which would significantly alleviate the financial burden of acquiring a new phone.
Lastly, Silva emphasizes the importance of investigating additional monthly fees, including those related to data speeds and insurance. I might qualify for special deals, particularly if I work in sectors like education, healthcare, or the military.
“The first thing I would suggest is to ask about what phones are available … what are the monthly fees, and how much can I get for my trade-in,” he adds. “Then, I would inquire about any additional discounts you might offer.”
Key Considerations for Your Cell Phone Purchase
Ultimately, the decision of whether to purchase a phone outright or finance it over several months is a deeply personal choice that “depends on your financial circumstances, goals, and preferences,” O’Brien concludes. Regardless of how I proceed, it’s crucial to conduct thorough research on my equipment needs, pricing plans, and available discounts to make an informed decision.
Explore More Valuable Insights from Money:
When Should I Consider Using ‘Buy Now, Pay Later’ Applications?
Am I Being Misled Into Spending More Money?
Are Store Credit Cards a Smart Financial Choice?
