Soaring prices have prompted many Americans to seek innovative strategies for saving on holiday gifts this year. According to Deloitte’s 2025 Holiday Retail Survey, around 50% of respondents indicated that they plan to create DIY gifts as a budget-friendly option this season. Additionally, nearly 40% of survey participants are considering giving handmade presents, while about 30% intend to prepare homemade food gifts.
This approach appears to be an excellent method to save money while embracing the holiday spirit. There’s an abundance of Pinterest boards and YouTube tutorials available for those seeking inspiration and guidance on their creative endeavors.
A simple Google search yields a plethora of advice for crafting DIY sugar scrubs, bath bombs, decorative baskets, coasters, candles, knitting, and wreaths. The options are seemingly endless, especially when considering a wide array of cooked, baked, and canned goodies.
However, experts in cooking and crafting emphasize that careful planning is essential to ensure that your homemade holiday gifts do not disrupt your budget. “While making your own gifts can lead to savings, it can also become quite costly,” warns Sara Croymans, an extension educator in the department of family, health, and well-being at the University of Minnesota Extension. “We strongly encourage individuals to plan ahead to understand their project scope.”
What distinguishes a successful DIY gift-giver from others? Croymans highlights that preparation is crucial. “Successful DIYers maintain a list, establish a budget, and commence their projects early,” she states.
Whether you’re stitching, stirring, or stamping, industry experts identify several costly pitfalls that can jeopardize your budget-friendly plans. Here’s what the professionals recommend avoiding, along with alternative strategies to implement instead.
Discover Affordable Craft Supplies Beyond Specialty Stores
“I seldom shop at specialty stores because I find them to be overpriced,” shares Marlene Alexander, founder of the Dollar Store Style blog, in an email. Instead, experts advocate exploring dollar stores, warehouse clubs, and big-box retailers for more affordable supplies.
Another invaluable tip from experts: You can often find better deals on materials and ingredients, particularly when purchasing in bulk, by sourcing from the same locations frequented by professionals. “Visiting restaurant supply stores can lead to significant savings,” advises Luci Mosesso, a 4-H agent at West Virginia University Extension.
All experts consulted by Money also recommend exploring local thrift stores for supplies and containers. “Thrift stores are fantastic for sourcing DIY supplies,” Croymans affirms. “You can discover a wealth of crafty items, which is also beneficial for the environment.”
Why You Should Avoid Purchasing Expensive Crafting Kits
While a crafting kit that provides all necessary components to create a project, such as a needlepoint pillow or a beaded basket, may seem convenient, it often comes with a hefty price tag.
“Ready-made craft kits are designed for convenience but are usually pricier than gathering the individual components yourself,” Alexander advises.
If you are a beginner in embroidery or beadwork, take note of what a complete kit includes: you can likely acquire the individual components at a lower cost, she adds.
However, there are exceptions, Croymans mentions. If you only require a small quantity of a specific ingredient or material and have no intent to use the remainder, purchasing a kit might be a practical choice.
How to Utilize What You Already Have for Your DIY Gifts
While inexpensive supplies are beneficial, utilizing free resources can yield even greater savings. Assess what you already possess; you may be pleasantly surprised to find ways to reduce your gift budget while simultaneously decluttering your space.
For instance, if you frequently sew, Alex Mathias, an assistant professor and 4-H agent at West Virginia University Extension, suggests repurposing fabric scraps rather than acquiring new materials. If your projects involve natural elements, consider foraging for branches, pinecones, and other items.
In light of this, she recommends selecting projects that utilize easily sourced items. “Be open to inspiration rather than solely searching for something specific,” she advises.
Avoid Overspending on Packaging and Presentation
Mathias warns that presentation and packaging can lead to unexpected expenses. “The containers used for gifts can be quite pricey,” she notes. “Utilizing items like Christmas-themed Ziploc bags or colorful Saran wrap can create a festive flair without the need for elaborate ribbons and wrapping, especially for food items.”
Another common pitfall to sidestep: striving for uniformity in presentation. While a neat stack of identical plates filled with treats may create a visually appealing display, recipients will not recognize if their gift resembles another. “Each gift can look different because you are giving them to various people,” Mathias points out.
Why Mastering Your Crafting Skills is Essential for Budget Success
For novice crafters or cooks, mismanaging the execution can significantly impact your budget. Those adept at rolling out pastry dough or sewing potholders often understand the importance of investing time and effort to develop specialized skills.
“If someone is new to crafting, it’s beneficial to watch or read a tutorial to ensure they understand the process, which helps avoid wasting time and resources,” Alexander recommends.
Mathias emphasizes going further. “Explore several tutorials or recipes to see different approaches to what you intend to create,” she suggests. Allocate sufficient time so you do not become stressed and overlook crucial steps, she adds.
“It will always take longer than expected… Set realistic goals for who you plan to gift without overwhelming yourself.”
How to Avoid Investing in Costly Equipment for Your Projects
If your plans to bake delightful treats for loved ones do not necessitate any equipment beyond a stand mixer you already own, you’re in great shape. However, many DIY gift-givers mistakenly believe they need to purchase expensive equipment, Mathias explains, even though that is often unnecessary.
Alternative methods or equipment may be available that won’t strain your finances. Consider borrowing or renting the specialized equipment needed for your projects.
Seek assistance from local “buy nothing” groups and do some research. Available resources may vary by location, but you might discover that you reside near a commercial kitchen, sewing studio, or other maker space where you can rent the equipment you need for a nominal fee.
Don’t forget to check your local library, as well. A growing number of libraries now offer the option to borrow craft equipment alongside the latest bestsellers.
Why You Don’t Need to Create Everything From Scratch
Similar to transforming a boxed cake mix into a delightful dessert, you might find more cost-effective options by purchasing and customizing items instead of starting from raw materials. For example, consider buying plain kitchen towels from a dollar store and dyeing them or adding stamped designs, rather than purchasing fabric and sewing them from scratch.
“Keeping projects simple can lead to significant savings. Selecting projects that align with your skill set also helps,” Croymans states. Even if you lack crafting skills, assembling a gift basket requires no specialized expertise.
Ultimately, she reminds us of the essential gift-giving principle: It’s the thought that counts.
Explore More Insights from Money:
Could ChatGPT Be Your Secret Weapon This Holiday Shopping Season?
Discover 6 Ways Americans Are Financing Their Holiday Gifts This Year
Why Giving a Car as a Holiday Gift May Not Be the Best Idea
