The onset of a new year prompts a longstanding, crucial question regarding how retirees can effectively manage their retirement savings for optimal benefits.
Are you an individual who prefers to tackle tasks promptly rather than procrastinating? If you answered yes, and you will be 73 or older anytime in 2026, you might feel inclined to withdraw your required minimum distribution from your IRA as soon as this month. This could indeed be a wise decision tailored to your specific financial situation.
However, it is essential to engage in some careful strategic planning regarding the timing of your decision. In certain circumstances, it may be more prudent to delay your withdrawal, even if this choice feels slightly uncomfortable.
Before proceeding, let’s clarify some important aspects.
Understanding Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs) and Their Functionality
If you are unfamiliar with the term, a required minimum distribution, or RMD, refers to an IRS-mandated taxable withdrawal from the majority of standard retirement accounts. Notably, Roth IRAs are exempt from these regulations since withdrawals from Roth accounts are not subject to taxation.
These withdrawals are not obligatory until you reach the age of 73. Upon reaching this milestone, however, you must make annual withdrawals before the end of the calendar year. The only exception applies to your first withdrawal, which you can postpone until April 1 of the year following your 73rd birthday. Nonetheless, it is generally advisable to avoid delaying the first distribution, as doing so would result in receiving two taxable distributions within the same year.
What is the minimum amount that must be withdrawn? It varies based on your age and the total value of your retirement accounts at the close of the previous year. As you grow older, the percentage of your retirement funds that you need to withdraw increases. For example, when you turn 73, you will be required to take out just under 3.8% of your account balance. Conversely, if you are 85 years old, you must withdraw 6.25%, and by age 100, the percentage rises to over 15.6% of the prior year’s ending balance. Your brokerage or IRA custodian can provide you with the year-end values of your accounts, but you will need to calculate your own RMD using worksheets available from the IRS.
While there is a minimum amount required, keep in mind that there is no upper limit on how much you can withdraw. However, larger distributions inevitably lead to heftier tax liabilities.
Image source: Getty Images.
Additionally, you do have some flexibility in how you take your required minimum distributions. If you possess multiple ordinary IRAs, for example, you can aggregate their total year-end values and then withdraw the calculated RMD from just one account. This same principle applies to 403(b) plans, provided you do not mix traditional IRAs with 403(b) accounts for RMD calculations.
However, this flexibility does not extend to 401(k) accounts. If you have more than one 401(k), you must calculate and withdraw separate RMDs for each account. An important exception exists if you are still employed and actively contributing to a 401(k) plan; in this case, you do not have to take a required distribution from that specific 401(k), even if you must take RMDs from plans associated with previous employers.
It is worth noting that the IRS treats an IRA funded by a rollover from a 401(k) as a traditional IRA, meaning rollover retirement accounts are also subject to the same RMD regulations and options as traditional IRAs.
Still, the pressing question is: Is it wise to take your RMD in January of this year, or in any January?
Strategize Your RMD Timing for Maximum Benefit
The timing of your RMD hinges on various factors, some of which may hold more significance for you than others. For instance, if you do not require immediate cash and prefer to transfer existing assets from a retirement account to a standard brokerage account for safekeeping, this is indeed a viable option known as an in-kind transfer. Simply instruct your IRA custodian to proceed, and they will inform you of your precise taxable RMD based on the day the transfer is finalized.
For the majority of investors, however, since the RMD will likely be executed with cash generated from selling stocks, bonds, or funds, which may contribute to your essential retirement income, optimizing the timing of your required distribution is crucial. In essence, you want to sell assets when their value is higher rather than lower, allowing more funds to remain in the retirement account for continued tax-free growth. Keep in mind that an RMD is merely a dollar amount determined at the end of the preceding year. The IRS does not concern itself with how or when you acquire the funds; it only mandates that you fulfill your RMD before the year-end deadline.
To address the question, with the S&P 500 currently trading at all-time highs following a remarkable 40% increase since April, taking your RMD this month is certainly a reasonable choice.
At first glance, this may seem akin to market timing, which investors are typically advised to avoid due to its inherent challenges. It is indeed possible that the S&P 500 could reach higher levels in the coming months, following its natural upward trajectory.
However, this approach is more aligned with effective risk management.
If it assists in your decision-making, consider staggering your required distribution throughout the year ahead. This strategy will balance your withdrawals and may yield an average exit price around the S&P 500’s midpoint for the year. This approach can prove beneficial.
The most significant risk lies in delaying your withdrawal in hopes of selling stocks at their peak for the year. The longer you wait, the more the opportunity to maximize your exit diminishes. You might end up running out of time before achieving the optimum exit point you were hoping for.
Nevertheless, do not rush into a decision just yet. You still have over 350 days available to weigh your options.
